Buying at Private Sale vs Auction

Understanding the differences can help you make a more confident and informed decision.

First Home Buyer Guide

Am I ready to buy a house?

What is a first home buyer?

Will I be able to get a loan?

Is my Credit History and Rental History important?

Buying versus renting

How much deposit do I need?

Understanding deposits

How to meet the banks genuine savings rules

Deposit calculator

Grants and schemes for FHB's

First Home Owner Grants

First Home Guarantee Scheme

Latest government announcements to help FHB’s

Getting finance pre-approval

Pre-approval process

Benefits of getting a pre-approval

Are all pre-approvals equal?

Mortgage brokers vs Banks?

Why use a mortgage broker?

How much does a mortgage broker cost?

Are all mortgage brokers equal?

How to buy a property

Pre-approval process

Benefits of getting a pre-approval

Are all pre-approvals equal?

Preparing for settlement

Going unconditional on the property contract

What does a converyancer/solicitor do for a property purchase?

What happens on the day of settlement?

Managing your mortgage

Understanding loan repayments

Extra repayments, redraw and offset accounts

When is the right time to review your home loan?

When it comes to selling a property, most homeowners choose between two main options: a private sale or an auction. Each method has its own benefits and drawbacks, depending on the property, market conditions, and your goals as a seller.

What Is a Private Sale?

A private sale is when a property is sold directly to a buyer without going to auction. You can sell it yourself or use a real estate agent to handle the process.

In a private sale, the property is listed with a set asking price or price guide. Interested buyers make offers, and the seller can negotiate until both parties agree on a final price.

This is the most common way to sell property in many areas and tends to suit a wide range of situations, especially when there’s no urgent deadline.

Pros and Cons of a Private Sale

Pros	Cons
More time to consider offers	May take longer to sell
Greater control over negotiations	Buyers can negotiate aggressively
Less pressure than a public auction	Harder to create urgency or competition
Can be more private and low-key	Risk of under-pricing or fewer competing offers

Private sales can be ideal for sellers who value privacy, flexibility, and control. However, without the competitive element of an auction, it can be harder to generate urgency or drive up the price.

What Is an Auction?

An auction is a public sale held at a set time and date, where buyers bid against each other. The property is sold to the highest bidder, provided the reserve price (the minimum amount the seller will accept) is met.

Auctions are often fast-paced and are usually run by a professional auctioneer, either on-site or online. This method is commonly used in competitive markets or for properties that are unique or hard to price.

Pros and Cons of an Auction

Pros	Cons
Creates urgency and competition	High-pressure environment for sellers and buyers
Can result in a higher sale price	No guarantee the reserve will be met
Set sale date for faster results	Marketing and auctioneer costs can be higher
Transparent process for all parties	Not ideal for all property types or locations

While auctions can create bidding wars and fast results, they require solid preparation. Buyers should have their finances sorted and be ready to commit. Sellers, meanwhile, should understand the psychology of bidding; and the tactics buyers might use to keep prices down. Our article on negotiation traps has some great insights worth reading before you consider the next stage of either your buying or selling journey.

Private Sale vs Auction: Buyer Perspective

From a buyer’s point of view, each method also comes with different experiences, risks, and benefits.

Private Sale – Buyer View

Pros	Cons
More time to inspect and make offers	May involve back-and-forth negotiation
Potential to negotiate price or terms	Less urgency may result in missing out
No need to compete in a live auction	Less transparency on competing offers

Private sales give buyers more time and flexibility, but there’s less transparency and the risk that you could be outbid without even knowing it.

Auction – Buyer View

Pros	Cons
Transparent bidding process	Emotion and competition can push prices up
Fast, definitive outcome on auction day	Requires finance to be sorted in advance
All buyers have equal opportunity	No cooling-off period after purchase

Auctions are all about preparation and confidence. If you’re new to the process, a buyer’s agent can be a game-changer. Not sure about what a buyers agent does or how they can assist you? Our buyers agent page has all the information you’ll need!

Which Selling Method Is Right for You?

Choosing between a private sale and an auction really depends on your situation. There’s no one-size-fits-all approach, but here are a few scenarios where one method might suit better than the other:

When a Private Sale Works Best

A private sale may be the way to go if:

You’re not in a hurry and want to take your time.
You prefer a low-pressure and private approach.
The market is slower or less competitive.
Your home appeals to a niche audience.

Private sales are also useful when you want the flexibility to negotiate price and terms or avoid the public spotlight of an auction campaign.

When an Auction Might Be Better

Consider an auction if:

The property is in a high-demand area.
You want to create competition and urgency.
You’re working with a tight deadline (e.g., relocation or financial need).
The home has unique features that make it hard to price.

Auctions give you a set timeline, a potentially higher price, and a clear, public sales process. They work best when multiple buyers are likely to compete for your home.

What About Expressions of Interest?

If you’re unsure whether to go private or auction, you might consider a hybrid method, such as:

Expressions of Interest (EOI) – Buyers submit their best offer by a deadline.
Sale by Tender – Similar to EOI but often more formal and sealed.

These approaches can offer the best of both worlds: some urgency and competition, but still behind closed doors with room to negotiate.

Costs to Consider

Don’t forget about the costs involved in each method:

Private Sale: Agent commission, advertising, potential staging and photography.
Auction: All the above, plus auctioneer fees and often more intensive marketing to attract bidders.

Work with your agent to understand the full cost breakdown for each method and what’s most likely to get the best return in your situation.

Summing Up

Whether you sell by private treaty or at auction, success comes down to strategy, timing, and preparation. Ask yourself:

Do I want more control or speed?
Is my property likely to attract competitive buyers?
Do I have time to wait for the right offer?
What is the local market doing right now?

Both selling methods have their place, and with the right support, you can make either option work in your favour.

Thinking of Selling?

Still unsure whether a private sale or auction is right for your property?

Chat with a local broker today to get expert advice tailored to your situation. Whether you’re just exploring your options or ready to list, having a trusted professional on your side makes all the difference